When Betrayal Trauma Made Me Silence My Feelings

A look back at how betrayal trauma led me to silence my feelings while trying to support my husband’s addiction recovery.

BETRAYAL TRAUMAWIP

Laura Esh

11/16/20266 min read

grayscale photo of woman doing silent hand sign
grayscale photo of woman doing silent hand sign

It’s been sixteen years since my disclosures. Can you believe it?

Yeah, me either.

I thought it would be fun (in a goodness gracious, she’s changed a lot kinda way) to look at what I wrote back in the day.

Then reflect on what I think about it now. The subject…my response to compartmentalization!

Here’s what I wrote back in the day:

Like the threat of venomous snake’s bite, Compartmentalization showed herself to me briefly yesterday morning as she ran across the hazel of my husband’s eyes. In a blink she was gone but not before leaving a slight tear across my stomach causing it to awaken. Familiar feelings of doubt entered into my brain and caused me to enter into a state of hyper arousal.

Rather than fight the feeling, I allowed myself to stay a in a low state of vigilance, remaining aware of any red flags the remainder of the day and reflect back upon what had just happened a few minutes earlier to cause the look in his eyes.

I proceeded with my day using calming techniques to avoid escalating into full hyper arousal and hyper vigilant activities. I left the house to stay away from his computers so I didn’t hack into them. I ran around and stay busy. I meditated, I affirmed my strengths and I assured myself that the gut instinct I had was real and not imagined.

Throughout the day the red flags began to reveal themselves to me. The various telltale signs that he shows when he had a slip or relapse. The urge to confront him about my suspicions was strong but I waited until our FANOS session that evening.

During FANOS, “O” is for OWERSHIP – a chance to apologize for any wrong doings, however he’d been using this as a chance to say “it's been another sober day” for the last two weeks and using “S” as his list for what he’s done for Self-care to keep sober.

We each took our turns and as the same for the last two weeks, “been another sober day” left his lips, compartmentalization showed herself to me yet again. She was lurking behind his eyes, and he quickly turned away from me.

When asked again, the truth of the relapse came out in full. He broke one of his inner-circle behaviors. When he told me, I didn’t get angry, I didn’t cry, I simply thanked him for being honest and reminded him about the importance of being open and honest with me during FANOS the first time.

He responded by letting me know that because I didn’t get upset, I had made it easier for him to do just that if a slip or relapse happened again. He went on to assure me what happened and that it didn't include any other bottom-line behaviors.

After FANOS we sat and we talked for a long, long time.

When Compartmentalization showed herself to me again in the form of denial just a few days later in his eyes, I was saddened. She never ceases to amaze me by her never-ending supply of masks. She is a sneaky little bitch. I hope my husband can kick her ass because I want him back from her. I miss him terribly.

^^^^^^^^^

The first thing I notice is, wow, even back then I had a flair for dramatic writing.

I can also hear my pain through my words. I recognize how much I loved my then-husband. How much I wanted him to succeed in his recovery and healing, even while I was grasping to navigate my way through hypervigilance and betrayal trauma.

It was written in 2012, so my healing was still in its infancy. I was barely holding on myself. My second disclosure was in December 2010. I didn’t get help for myself for about nine or ten months…so yeah…I was barely crawling, and I definitely hadn’t found my Healing Hive quite yet, but I was working on it.

By then, I was seeing my amazing counselor, so I was gathering some tools, but I can see some things I’d do differently now.

First of all, was I right that he was compartmentalizing? I don’t know. Maybe. Who’s to say? Only he would know for sure. But I was trying to crawl inside his brain with him; that’s for certain.

Was I drawing from experience? Maybe a bit. It’s certainly something I was able to do when I was active with my recovery, ”Gotta go to work and earn that money.” “Hey, Vinny, you got an eighth I can pick up?”

Also, while I was healing from betrayal trauma. “Hey kids, how was school?!” “What? No, I’m perfectly fine! I haven’t been triggering all fucking day!”

But for me to try to get inside his head without even talking to him first? Bananas on splits.

Then the way I went about FANOS. Cringeville.

A great tool created by Debra and Mark Lasser when used correctly:

F: Feeling

A: Affirmations

N: Needs

O: Ownership

S: Self-care/Sobriety

It’s clear that we’d transgressed into doing it all willy-nilly.

Kinda like how he approached being honest in the check-in conversation.

Lying was a huge deal to me. And he did it. But notice my reaction…I thanked him for being honest…eventually.

Lying was devastating enough to me to make it into my original (albeit very flawed) boundary agreement (hey, it was written the day after my second disclosure):

“I will not continue to put up with lies, distortion of truth, or not being entirely up front with me – even if you think you’re trying to protect me in some way. Honesty is always better for me. It keeps me grounded and keeps my mind from wandering into places I prefer it not to (questioning your sobriety, the past, etc.).

I promise not to lie to you, and you must promise not to lie (or stretch the truth) to me. The consequence for lying will be no affection except during the discussion of the disclosure of the lie and an occasional kiss on the lips.

There will be no hugging, snuggling, or any other affection for the day the lie is found out and two additional days.

Please understand, a lie can bring me back to ground zero in the trust factor with you, even a small lie. If your lying continues to be an issue, this will cause me to leave you because it causes me too much mental anguish.”

Damn, that’s extreme! But it does show how much I despise (present tense) lying. He thrived off my affection for him. He loved being loved and feeling my hugs and kisses, and when I took that away, it hurt him. It hurt me too, but I thought it was a “reasonable consequence,” not a form of control or punishment at the time. Yikes on bikes!

And yet, I protected his feelings above my own. I placed my feelings on a shelf in a jar, and put his front and center.

I silenced my thoughts.

I silenced my emotions.

I silenced my safe space in FANOS.

I know why I did it too.

His sobriety was still fragile. His emotions were still fragile.

I thought I needed to protect him.

Like a baby bird in the nest. He was a fledgling waiting to take flight. But I needed to make sure life didn’t attack him.

What about the emotions I encased in a jar collecting dust on the shelf?

I left them there, while I protected him from himself, thinking I was helping him on his journey.

After all, he said, when I didn’t react, it made it easier for him to open up to me.

And when I saw that he was struggling again, did I do anything? Say anything? No.

Because even though we had agreed to talk things through, I was too scared. The shoe had just dropped. What if the next setback was worse? What if he cheated again? Because even though I had this signed boundary agreement- yes, it was actually signed- I was still so unsure of things, even after a year had just passed.

2026 Laura would pull a Meredith and Lisa and say, “Hypocrisy and bullshit, bullshit, bullshit!”

Then honored my healthier, updated boundary. We would sit down, talk, and communicate. No more punishments. And if the lying continued, well, then I’d protect my emotional wellbeing and leave.

But 2012 Laura compartmentalized her feelings in the hopes that he would stop lying. That my marriage could have the ending I thought it would.

As the jars continued to collect dust on my shelf.

Let’s Stay Connected

If this resonates with you, I’d really love to know. You can comment below or email me. Don’t forget to sign up for my newsletter for exclusive content.

And if you’re looking for deeper exercises, I wrote Bookends of Recovery & Healing Workbook to help you heal from betrayal trauma and addiction by using creative exercises, action tools, and guided reflection.

I’m also available for limited coaching hours.

Warmly,
Laura
🌻

Recovery and healing are possible, even when the path forward looks different from what we expected.

I'm not a therapist. I'm writing from my own experiences and perspectives.

This website, podcast, workbooks, and their content are copyrighted by Laura and Bookends of Recovery and Healing – © 2026. All rights reserved.